Lets say I have a location names like
If one of them is 100% of the value, what will be the value of other extensions?
Newyork.us 100% (if location is in America, obviously)
Newyork.net 30% (.net sucks for location type sites/domains)
With your example newyork I would rank as follows.
newyork.us will be best
No question in my view that newyork.org is far and away the best.
I think that .info is much stronger for locations.
.net doesn’t go that well with location/city names as compared to .info, .net is best suited for commercial and networking related sites. Even .org doesn’t match that well for a city name unless ofcourse it’s for an organisation based in that particular city.